Top 10 Compact Sedans 2021 — Best Overall + Best Value
Top 10 Compact Sedans 2021 — Best Overall + Best Value
Direct Answer
For the 2021 model year, the Honda Civic is our Best Overall compact sedan, with a starting MSRP of $22,245. It blends a roomy cabin, the segment's best driving dynamics, strong resale value, and standard Honda Sensing safety tech into a package that simply does everything well.
Our Best Value pick is the 2021 Kia Forte, starting at $17,890, because no other small sedan pairs a sub-$18K price with a class-leading 10-year/100,000-mile powertrain warranty, up to 40 mpg highway, and a standard 8-inch touchscreen. If you want maximum fuel economy, the newly launched 2021 Hyundai Elantra Hybrid and the 2021 Toyota Corolla Hybrid both crack 50-plus mpg combined, and if you want an upscale feel, the 2021 Mazda3 is the most premium choice in the class.
How We Ranked the Top 10
We scored every 2021 compact sedan against a weighted rubric built from objective ownership data, EPA figures, and independent crash testing. The weighting:
- Reliability and ownership cost — 25%. Long-term dependability, projected resale, and maintenance costs (J.D. Power, KBB 5-Year Cost to Own).
- Efficiency and powertrain — 20%. EPA-rated MPG, horsepower, and how the engine feels day to day.
- Safety — 20%. IIHS crash ratings and Top Safety Pick status, plus NHTSA scores and standard driver-assist tech.
- Value and tech — 15%. Standard infotainment, features per dollar, and warranty coverage.
- Comfort — 10%. Ride quality, cabin materials, seat support, and rear-seat room.
- Price-to-performance — 10%. What the MSRP buys in driving enjoyment and content.
Sources include Car and Driver, MotorTrend, Edmunds, Kelley Blue Book, U.S. News, the IIHS, and EPA fueleconomy.gov. All prices are 2021 model-year MSRP and exclude destination unless noted.
1. Honda Civic 🏆 BEST OVERALL
Starting MSRP: $22,245 | Best for: Buyers who want one car that does everything well
The 2021 Civic sedan pairs a standard 2.0-liter four-cylinder making 174 hp (LX and Sport) or an available 1.5-liter turbo on EX and Touring trims, sending power through a CVT to the front wheels (FWD). The EX returns up to 36 mpg combined per the EPA, and the trunk holds a generous 14.8 cubic feet.
Every Civic includes the Honda Sensing suite of driver aids, and the car earned an IIHS Top Safety Pick with a five-star overall NHTSA rating. Warranty is the standard 3-year/36,000-mile basic and 5-year/60,000-mile powertrain.
Pros:
- Best-in-class handling and steering feel
- Roomy cabin and huge trunk for the segment
- Excellent resale value and proven reliability
- Honda Sensing safety tech standard across the line
Cons:
- Base infotainment graphics look dated next to rivals
- Touring trim pushes well past $28K
Verdict: The Civic is the benchmark every other compact sedan is measured against, and for 2021 it still wins.
2. Toyota Corolla Hybrid 💎 BEST VALUE (efficiency) — and runner-up overall
Starting MSRP: $23,400 | Best for: Commuters chasing maximum MPG with bulletproof reliability
The 2021 Corolla Hybrid uses a 1.8-liter four-cylinder paired with two electric motors for 121 combined horsepower, driving the front wheels (FWD) through an electronic CVT. The EPA rates it at an outstanding 53 mpg city / 52 mpg highway, among the best of any non-plug-in sedan sold in 2021.
The trunk holds 13.1 cubic feet, and Toyota Safety Sense 2.0 is standard. The Corolla earned an IIHS Top Safety Pick and Toyota's reputation for durability is unmatched.
Pros:
- 53 mpg city, near the top of the entire class
- Legendary Toyota reliability and low cost to own
- Toyota Safety Sense 2.0 standard
- No range anxiety — it is a regular hybrid
Cons:
- Only 121 hp, so acceleration is leisurely
- Firmer ride and modest cabin materials
Verdict: If you measure value in pennies per mile over a decade, the Corolla Hybrid is nearly impossible to beat.
3. Hyundai Elantra (redesigned 2021)
Starting MSRP: $19,650 | Best for: Style-first shoppers who want a long warranty
Fully redesigned for 2021, the Elantra rides on a sharp new platform with a 2.0-liter four making 147 hp and a CVT driving the front wheels (FWD). It returns up to 37 mpg combined, and the SEL and higher trims add a large dual-screen dashboard. The trunk measures 14.2 cubic feet, and the Elantra earned an IIHS Top Safety Pick.
Hyundai's 10-year/100,000-mile powertrain warranty is a major draw.
Pros:
- Bold, distinctive exterior styling
- Long 10-year/100,000-mile powertrain warranty
- Spacious cabin and large available screens
- Strong 37 mpg combined efficiency
Cons:
- Base 147-hp engine is merely adequate
- Some hard interior plastics on lower trims
Verdict: A dramatic redesign makes the 2021 Elantra one of the most compelling fresh faces in the class.
4. Hyundai Elantra Hybrid (new for 2021)
Starting MSRP: $23,550 | Best for: Efficiency seekers who also want a refined ride
New for 2021, the Elantra Hybrid mates a 1.6-liter four with an electric motor for 139 combined hp and, unusually for a hybrid, a 6-speed dual-clutch automatic rather than a CVT, driving the front wheels (FWD). EPA figures reach 53 mpg city / 56 mpg highway on the Blue trim.
It shares the standard Elantra's 14.2-cubic-foot trunk, IIHS Top Safety Pick rating, and 10-year/100,000-mile powertrain warranty.
Pros:
- Up to 54 mpg combined on the Blue trim
- Dual-clutch automatic feels more engaging than a CVT
- Smooth, quiet, upscale ride
- Excellent warranty coverage
Cons:
- Costs more than the Corolla Hybrid to start
- Dual-clutch can feel hesitant in slow traffic
Verdict: A genuinely refined hybrid that out-styles and out-feels most rivals at the price.
5. Mazda3
Starting MSRP: $20,650 | Best for: Drivers who want a premium, near-luxury feel
The 2021 Mazda3 is the upscale choice, with a base 2.0-liter (155 hp) or available 2.5-liter (186 hp), plus an available 2.5-liter turbo making 250 hp. All-wheel drive (AWD) is a $1,400 option on 2.5L trims, a rarity in the segment. The 2.5L FWD sedan returns about 30 mpg combined, and the trunk holds 13.2 cubic feet.
It earned the top IIHS Top Safety Pick+ with Good scores in all six crash tests.
Pros:
- Genuinely premium cabin materials and design
- Available AWD, almost unique in this class
- Top Safety Pick+ from the IIHS
- Engaging, composed handling
Cons:
- Tighter rear seat and smaller trunk than rivals
- Infotainment uses a knob, not a touchscreen, while driving
Verdict: The Mazda3 punches far above its price for buyers who value how a car looks and feels.
6. Kia Forte 💎 BEST VALUE
Starting MSRP: $17,890 | Best for: Budget shoppers who want the most car per dollar
The 2021 Forte undercuts almost everything here while delivering a 2.0-liter four making 147 hp with an efficient CVT (the GT trim swaps in a 201-hp 1.6-liter turbo). The base engine returns up to 29 mpg city / 40 mpg highway, and the 15.3-cubic-foot trunk is the largest in this group.
Power goes to the front wheels (FWD). A standard 8-inch touchscreen, IIHS Top Safety Pick rating, and Kia's 10-year/100,000-mile powertrain warranty seal the value case.
Pros:
- Lowest starting price in the class
- Class-leading 15.3-cubic-foot trunk
- 40 mpg highway and a long warranty
- Available 201-hp Forte GT for fun seekers
Cons:
- Base ride and steering trail the Civic and Mazda3
- Lower trims feel plain inside
Verdict: Dollar for dollar, nothing here beats the Forte — our clear value champion.
7. Toyota Corolla
Starting MSRP: $20,025 | Best for: No-fuss buyers who prioritize dependability
The standard 2021 Corolla offers a 1.8-liter (139 hp) or available 2.0-liter (169 hp) four-cylinder driving the front wheels (FWD) through a CVT. The 1.8L returns roughly 34 mpg combined, and Toyota Safety Sense 2.0 comes standard. The trunk holds 13.1 cubic feet, and the Corolla earned an IIHS Top Safety Pick plus strong NHTSA scores.
Resale and reliability are top-tier.
Pros:
- Outstanding reliability and resale value
- Toyota Safety Sense 2.0 standard
- Available 169-hp engine adds welcome punch
- Comfortable, quiet daily driver
Cons:
- Base 1.8-liter feels slow
- Rear seat is tighter than the Civic's
Verdict: A safe, sensible buy that holds its value better than almost anything in the class.
8. Nissan Sentra (redesigned 2020)
Starting MSRP: $19,510 | Best for: Shoppers who want style and a lot of standard content
Riding on its 2020 redesign, the 2021 Sentra runs a 2.0-liter four making 149 hp through a CVT to the front wheels (FWD). The EPA rates it at 29 mpg city / 39 mpg highway, and the trunk holds 14.3 cubic feet. Nissan Safety Shield 360 is standard.
With available LED headlights, the Sentra earns an IIHS Top Safety Pick; note the base halogen headlights are rated Poor, so the award applies only to SV and SR trims.
Pros:
- Attractive, mature exterior and cabin design
- Generous standard safety content
- Roomy 14.3-cubic-foot trunk
- Comfortable ride for the price
Cons:
- 149-hp CVT powertrain is uninspiring
- Top Safety Pick requires upgraded headlights
Verdict: A handsome, well-equipped value that looks more expensive than it is.
9. Volkswagen Jetta
Starting MSRP: $18,995 | Best for: Buyers who want a torquey turbo and German road feel
The 2021 Jetta is powered by a 1.4-liter turbocharged four making 147 hp and 184 lb-ft of torque, available with a 6-speed manual or 8-speed automatic driving the front wheels (FWD). That turbo torque helps it hit an EPA-rated 30 mpg city / 41 mpg highway, the best highway figure among non-hybrids here.
The trunk is a large 14.1 cubic feet, and the Jetta carries an IIHS Top Safety Pick rating. The sporty GLI adds a 228-hp turbo for enthusiasts.
Pros:
- 41 mpg highway, tops among gas-only rivals
- Available 6-speed manual transmission
- Roomy trunk and back seat
- Composed, planted highway manners
Cons:
- Cabin plastics feel plain for the badge
- Base audio and tech are modest
Verdict: The efficiency and available manual make the Jetta a distinctive, fun-to-drive value.
10. Subaru Impreza
Starting MSRP: $18,795 | Best for: Anyone who wants standard all-wheel drive on a budget
The Impreza is the only car here with standard all-wheel drive (AWD), powered by a 2.0-liter flat-four making 152 hp through a CVT or 5-speed manual. The CVT sedan returns about 32 mpg combined per the EPA. Standard EyeSight driver assists (on CVT models) help it earn an IIHS Top Safety Pick+, and the trunk holds 12.3 cubic feet.
Subaru's symmetrical AWD gives real all-weather confidence no rival here matches at the price.
Pros:
- Standard all-wheel drive, unique at this price
- Top Safety Pick+ and standard EyeSight on CVT trims
- Strong bad-weather and resale reputation
- Available 5-speed manual transmission
Cons:
- Only 152 hp, so it feels slow with AWD weight
- Smaller trunk than front-drive rivals
Verdict: If snow and confidence matter most, the Impreza's standard AWD makes it a smart outlier.
Buyer Decision Tree — Which One's Right for You?
What to Look For When Buying a Compact Sedan
- Real-world MPG, not just the headline number. Check the EPA combined figure on fueleconomy.gov and match it to your commute (city versus highway).
- Standard safety tech. Automatic emergency braking, lane-keeping, and adaptive cruise should be standard, not extra-cost. Confirm the IIHS Top Safety Pick applies to the trim you are buying — headlight ratings can change the award.
- Trunk and rear-seat space. Figures range from about 12.3 to 15.3 cubic feet here; sit in the back before you buy.
- Warranty coverage. Kia and Hyundai's 10-year/100,000-mile powertrain warranties are worth real money versus the 5-year norm.
- Total cost to own. Resale value, insurance, and maintenance often matter more than the sticker. Use KBB's 5-Year Cost to Own data.
- Horsepower matters less than marketing implies. Most buyers will never miss the difference between 147 and 174 hp in daily driving; ride comfort, visibility, and tech usability affect your day far more than peak power numbers.
FAQ
What is the best overall 2021 compact sedan? The 2021 Honda Civic earns our top spot for its balance of handling, space, safety, resale, and standard Honda Sensing tech, starting at $22,245.
Which 2021 compact sedan is the best value? The 2021 Kia Forte, starting at $17,890, pairs the lowest price with a 10-year/100,000-mile powertrain warranty, up to 40 mpg highway, and the largest trunk in the group.
Which 2021 compact sedan gets the best gas mileage? The Toyota Corolla Hybrid (53 mpg city) and the new Hyundai Elantra Hybrid (up to 54 mpg combined) lead the class for fuel economy.
Are any 2021 compact sedans available with all-wheel drive? Yes. The Subaru Impreza comes with standard AWD, and the Mazda3 offers AWD as a roughly $1,400 option on 2.5-liter trims.
Which 2021 compact sedans have the longest warranty? The Kia Forte and Hyundai Elantra both carry a 10-year/100,000-mile powertrain warranty, well beyond the 5-year/60,000-mile coverage from Honda and Toyota.
Was there a 2021 Honda Civic Si? No. Honda paused the Civic Si for the 2021 model year; enthusiasts seeking a factory hot version had the Civic Type R hatchback or the turbocharged Hyundai Elantra N Line and Kia Forte GT instead.
Bottom Line
The 2021 compact sedan field is deep, and you cannot make a truly bad choice among these ten. The Honda Civic earns Best Overall for doing everything well, from handling to safety to resale. The Kia Forte takes Best Value with the lowest price, biggest trunk, and longest warranty.
Efficiency shoppers should cross-shop the Corolla Hybrid and Elantra Hybrid, both topping 50 mpg; the standard-AWD Subaru Impreza suits snowy climates; and the Mazda3 wins on premium feel. Match the rubric to your priorities and one of these ten will fit.
Sources
- Honda Civic 2021 pricing and specs — Kelley Blue Book (kbb.com/honda/civic/2021)
- 2021 Honda Civic vs. 2021 Hyundai Elantra comparison — J.D. Power (jdpower.com)
- 2021 Toyota Corolla Hybrid specs and MPG — Cars.com (cars.com/research/toyota-corolla_hybrid-2021)
- 2021 Toyota Corolla Hybrid fuel economy — EPA fueleconomy.gov
- 2021 Hyundai Elantra Hybrid review and pricing — U.S. News (cars.usnews.com/cars-trucks/hyundai/elantra-hybrid/2021)
- 2021 Mazda3 review, ratings, and specs — The Car Connection (thecarconnection.com/overview/mazda_mazda3_2021)
- 2021 Kia Forte review and specs — The Car Connection (thecarconnection.com/overview/kia_forte_2021)
- 2021 Nissan Sentra specs and IIHS ratings — Cars.com (cars.com/research/nissan-sentra-2021)
- 2021 Volkswagen Jetta specs and MPG — Edmunds (edmunds.com/volkswagen/jetta/2021)
- 2021 Subaru Impreza pricing and specs — CarBuzz (carbuzz.com/cars/subaru/impreza-sedan/2021)
- IIHS Top Safety Pick ratings, 2021 — Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (iihs.org)
*Compact sedan review — compact sedan reviews, rating, best compact sedan 2021, and a review of the top small car picks for buyers.*